First off,
"noteworthy" is suspect since it indicates something inconsequential
or subsidiary, which in a book full of "notes" we can take to mean
exactly the opposite, that here in fact is something quite important (we could
have a long discussion on the status of the "note" in the Arcades Project).
The word conjunction
has a number of meanings, each of which becomes operative in the passage. Most
basically, it is (1) an action or instance of two or more events or things occurring
at the same point in time or space; (2) an alignment of two planets or other
celestial objects so that they appear to be in the same, or nearly the same,
place in the sky; and (3) a word used to connect clauses or sentences, or to coordinate
words in the same clause. So we want to keep aware of these three meanings as
we assess and notate this passage.
What experiences a
conjunction here, and how does that take place? Taking the passage at face
value, there is a conjunction, really meaning a relationship, between the Greek
branding of practical labor as a base aspiration for riches and the somewhat
later link to the denigration of the tradesman, or by extension of trade
itself. In the context of the section on idleness, which as we know is a primary
characteristic of the flaneur, these two tendencies position the idler as the
non-slave, someone opposed to the crass accumulation of money, with higher aspirations,
beyond capital, a true citizen of the polis, democratic. This idea of
conjunction is these two things happening in relation to each other.
The second idea of
conjunction gravitates toward the grammatical. The passage, or more precisely
the citation, shows how contempt for artisans and then trade as a whole was
baked into the very structures of words themselves. We first see how the word
for artisan, "banausos," was a synonym
for contempt! And in fact "everything related to tradespeople or to
handwork carries a stigma." We then see that the leisure/trade binary goes
even more deeply into the genetic makeup of language itself, with the
conjunction of schole/leisure and ascholia/business, and then otium/leisure
with neg-otium/business.
Lastly there is a
mythical or astral conjunction here since there is an association of leisure
with the heavenly, a conjoining of these two, as much as there is an
association and conjoining of the tradesman with the god Mammon.
No comments:
Post a Comment