At this point in
the discussion of experience, with its complexity and depth, we can only assume
that Benjamin had a chuckle when introducing this citation. But in fact this
little snippet is a masterpiece (if we can use that term). It's certainly
comic, somewhat destabilized to that degree, since it's a paternalistic (not to
say authoritarian) bit of advice for professional journalists, workers, that
states that the essence of their task is to convey within their writing an
"immediate experience," which, coincidentally (or is it?), happens to
be the operative term for the product of idleness as we've been discussing it.
Through this piece of workplace advice we have the perfect cipher for
the conjoining of the two types of experience Benjamin has been theorizing.
I
imagine a faster reading might stop here, smiling at the irony, and moving to
the next quote. And it is a nice irony! But this is only one of the levels on
which the citation operates: we can say that as much as humor is on the side of
idleness, the humor of this passage is an idle thing, we know that idleness, as
in the passage itself, is intimately conjoined with work, and here too, if we
flip this passage over, so to speak, and take it completely seriously, in a work-like manner, it functions
as a key methodological statement for the Arcades
Project itself. We can take it
seriously: the language not only picks up on discussions
of "immediate experience" but also echoes, most obviously, the central idea for the Arcades Project of the "now of recognizability" in the "vivid chronicle of what is
happening," so that indeed we can read this as specific advice from Benjamin
on how to achieve the primary objectives of the Arcades Project as a whole,
looking for an authentic "field," like the force fields mentioned in
m1a,4, the "documentary account," which might describe the documentary
nature of the Arcades Project, and so
on. The passage in many ways works as much as straightforward commentary as anything
in convolute N, in this case positioning the Arcades Project as
"reportage," a kind of daily drudge, but also with the highest of
aims, the literal documentation of "immediate experience." Almost
like a priceless collectible, it's extraordinary that Benjamin could even find
such a citation, as here it sits as an uncanny summary of the convolute and the
larger work, but beyond that a specimen and example of Benjamin's own ability
to be a "good" "professional" "journalist" who
has the "capacity for having an experience," in this case through
reading, through citation, copying, writing.
No comments:
Post a Comment